Transcript 0:00 Thanks for tuning in to Wit and Wisdom with Tom Green, where we start conversations on the things that really matter. This is episode number one hundred and fifty-seven of the Wit and Wisdom podcast. 0:12 If you enjoy this conversation, I hope you'll share this podcast with a few people you care about. We're always looking to make new friends. 0:21 One of the things people claim to like about Wit and Wisdom is that we never talk politics, and we never will. 0:27 But I think we can both agree that some states lean blue and some states lean red, and those leanings tend to make people in those states happy. But what about Canada? Which way does it lean? 0:38 And how do some of the policies that they're deploying leak across the border into the US? Like most things in politics, regardless of where you live, they start with the best of intentions. 0:50 In this case, to stop the needless suffering of people who are terminally ill. Well, that seems like a good cause. To relieve unbearable pain and give people a dignified exit when medicine has nothing left to offer. 1:03 Sounds good. It was ostensibly the ultimate act of compassion. It sounded humane and the kind of policy that belongs in a modern, civilized society, a society that believes mercy should trump misery. 1:17 And for many people, that promise felt like a final measure of kindness at the end of unbearably long road. In twenty sixteen, Canada introduced MAID, the Medical Assistance in Dying law. 1:32 Only a handful of people chose it, and only as a last resort. Back then, policymakers reassured citizens that strict guardrails would prevent any misuse. 1:43 They promised it would remain legal, safe, and rare, and used only in the narrowest, most heartbreaking situations. The public nodded along, trusting that compassion had limits, boundaries, and oversights. 2:00 By twenty twenty-three, more than sixty thousand people had committed suicide in Canada with the assistance of a physician. That's nearly five percent of all deaths in Canada. 2:12 Enough to fill New York's Madison Square Garden three times. Physician-assisted suicide now accounts for about one in twenty deaths in Canada, more than Alzheimer's and diabetes combined, 2:26 surpassing countries where assisted dying has been legal for far longer. And the slope wasn't gradual. It was a free fall. A program that once handled a few dozen cases a year now handles tens of thousands, 2:42 almost as if the country collectively slid into a new moral terrain without fully grasping the speed of the descent. So if you don't live in Canada, why should you care? 2:54 Well, if you live in the US, twelve states, mostly blue, offer various forms of medically assisted suicide. 3:02 These states often emphasize personal freedom over state control, especially in intimate life decisions like marriage, reproduction, and end-of-life care. 3:12 California's End of Life Option Act allows physicians to prescribe high-powered barbiturates for self-administration at home. The drug causes sedation, followed by respiratory arrest. 3:25 For many Americans, this fits into a long tradition of rugged individualism, the ultimate expression of freedom. But stacked underneath that sentiment is something else, 3:37 a growing fear of dependency, of indignity, and of being a burden on loved ones. I get it. Today in Canada, MAID is one of the fastest-growing medical services that are available. 3:50 Doctors receive between three hundred and five hundred dollars in government payments for ending a life. Fees in the US are significantly higher than in Canada because US patients often pay privately. 4:02 Some physicians charge as much as five thousand dollars to end a life in the US. That disparity should unsettle you. When a service becomes profitable, it rarely remains small. 4:15 Financial incentives have a way of transforming medical ethics. And when death becomes a billable, profitable venture, someone somewhere will eventually decide how to make an even bigger profit. 4:28 Imagine if private equity firms decide to get behind this initiative. Imagine the money that could flow into this. The concept of personal freedom in dying is gaining traction in the US. 4:41 A twenty twenty-four Gallup poll found that seventy-one percent of US adults believe doctors should be legally allowed to end a patient's life by some painless means. That is, if the patient and family request it. 4:54 But public opinion often reflects surface-level questions, not the deeper implications. Ask people if they want to avoid suffering, most will say yes, including me. 5:05 Ask them if they trust the government or healthcare bureaucracy to make life and death decisions responsibly, and the room goes quiet. The infomercial version of MAID in Canada is about terminal illness, 5:19 some dreadful form of cancer for which there's no effective treatment or cure. But the reality? People are choosing medical suicide not as an end to disease, but as an end to life's indignities. 5:33 The quiet humiliations that come along with aging, the fear of loneliness that feels terminal even when the body is not. These are not medical failings, they're societal failings. 5:46 And Canada's MAID program has become a mirror exposing them. In twenty twenty-one, Canada expanded the law to allow eligibility for people with what's known as severe suffering. 5:59 So far, no US states have expanded to this language, but you and I both know it's inevitable.Once lawmakers unlock a door, even slightly, future generations tend to run through it. 6:12 Today's exception becomes tomorrow's norm. There are hundreds of examples. The concern is the term severe suffering. Legally, that term can be expanded beyond illness. What about those suffering from dementia? 6:27 Or those who are lonely or disabled? Or those born with developmental disabilities? Do they have severe suffering? 6:36 They all qualify if they can convince a doctor that their situation results in severe suffering, regardless of whether that suffering may result in death. 6:44 And suffering, unlike a tumor or a failing organ, can't be measured on a scan. There's no objective test. It's incredibly easy to stretch the definition until it fits almost anyone who feels hopeless enough. 7:01 There's a concept in politics called the Overton window. It refers to the range of ideas the public currently sees as acceptable or mainstream. These days, few Americans can agree on a hundred percent on the same things. 7:16 And these days, it's highly dependent on who is suggesting the idea. Some people will oppose free water for all if it's suggested by the wrong person or the wrong party. Will everyone get the same amount? 7:29 What about the rich who tend to use more water than everyone else? Will everyone's water be treated with the same chemicals? Do I have to use the water the government provides, or can I buy my own? 7:39 As you can see, it's extremely difficult to get the Overton window to open or stay open. 7:46 For most people, the concept of ending suffering fits through the Overton window, but the window starts to close fast once you get into the details. Consider this. 7:57 In Ontario, nearly a third of severe suffering suicides lived in the poorest neighborhoods. Many say they would stick around if they had better housing, more disability support, or any kind of real social safety net. 8:10 That's a slippery slope. When the state offers death over medical treatment, it stops looking like compassion and starts looking a little dystopian. 8:21 Today, Canada excludes those solely with mental health conditions from MAID eligibility. But in March of '27, that exclusion expires. 8:31 Meantime, various advocacy groups are pursuing litigation, claiming that the law discriminates against people with mental health conditions and against minors. 8:40 So far, no US state allows physician-assisted suicide for mental health conditions. But litigation has a way of shifting the Overton window. 8:50 What begins as an edge case can become a precedent, and precedent has a very long memory. 8:58 For now, children are excluded, but Canada's own parliamentary committee has already studied whether so-called mature minors, that is, teenagers under eighteen deemed of capable of making medical decisions, should be eligible. 9:12 So think about that. A society debating whether a sixteen-year-old who can't legally drive or vote should be trusted to choose a medical death. If that doesn't give you pause, nothing will. 9:30 Some might suggest that the excessive cost of healthcare is to blame, but Canada has government-funded healthcare. Citizens pay little or nothing for their out-of-pocket care. 9:40 Patients often wait several months for specialty care, but the wait for medically assisted suicide is typically less than three weeks. 9:48 When the fastest service the state provides is death, you have to wonder whether convenience has replaced compassion, especially when eighty percent of all medical spending occurs in the last few months of life. 10:01 Meanwhile, those waiting for cancer surgery can wait up to eight weeks for treatment. That can seem like an eternity when your life is on the line. And in that eternity, fear grows. 10:12 People make decisions not out of clarity, but out of terror. That's not autonomy, that's desperation. In Quebec, MAID already accounts for seven percent of all deaths. 10:27 The government even considered expanding it to those with mental illness as their sole condition. That's been delayed, but the fact that it's even on the table should stop you cold. 10:37 Societies rarely debate ideas they find ro-- morally repugnant. The fact that this conversation is happening at all signals a cultural shift, a recalibration of what we consider acceptable. 10:51 The United Nations has warned Canada that its system risks becoming discriminatory against people with disabilities, that it tells them in effect, "We can't make your life better, but we can make it shorter." 11:03 Imagine hearing that message from your own government. Your surgery is denied, but your medically assisted suicide claim is approved. 11:13 Our history reminds us that it's not wise to allow government to be the arbiter of life's value or to define whose life is worth living or saving. The moral terrain can turn slippery overnight. 11:25 In the late nineteenth and twentieth centuries, eugenics ideas were circulating widely in Europe. German physicians, scientists, and social theorists were influenced by the concept of racial hygiene, 11:37 advocating for sterilization of the unfit, that is, those disabled or mentally ill. And we all know how that turned out. 11:47 The moment a society starts labeling certain lives as more worthy than others, the descent into cruelty begins with frightening speed. And the math is simple. 11:58 It costs far less to assist someone's death than to fund decades of medical care and support. That should horrify you, especially in a government-funded system. 12:08 Because once the accountants and actuaries get involved, morality becomes a rounding error.So here's where we are. Most people favor the concept of dignity in dying, including me. 12:22 But if we reduce it to dollars and cents, the balance sheet will always tilt towards death. We'd like to think that such cold calculations only exist in dystopian novels or movies. 12:33 But the speed, scale, and normalization of Made in Canada should give Americans pause, especially if you're a student of history. You might think that a program like this would be carefully managed in the U.S., 12:48 but did you know that by 1930s, more than 30 states had sterilization laws? The U.S. sterilized over 60,000 people under these programs, most without their consent. 12:59 California led the way, accounting for about a third of all sterilizations. And these weren't shadow operations. 13:05 They were widely supported, printed in newspapers, praised by academics, and justified with flowcharts and pseudoscience that looked authoritative at the time. 13:17 The Supreme Court of the United States, located in Washington, D.C., which interprets our laws, is the judicial branch of the U.S. government. Surely the Supreme Court wouldn't allow sterilizations, right? 13:29 Well, in 1927, the Supreme Court upheld Virginia's sterilization law. Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes famously wrote, Three generations of imbeciles is plenty. 13:42 That ruling was never formally overturned, though later decisions limited its scope. Holmes wasn't some fringe crank. He was one of the most celebrated jurists of his era. That's the cautionary tale. 13:56 Even brilliant people can be breathtakingly wrong when fear comes disguised as wisdom. As I said at the outset, things always begin with the best of intentions. 14:09 It always begins with compassion and the easing of suffering. And it always ends with convenience, with cleaning up the burdens on society. 14:18 In 2016, Canada policymakers promised MAID would be rare, a last resort for the terminally ill. But by 2023, it had become one of the fastest-growing medical procedures in the country. 14:30 By 2027, unless something changes, it will include mental illness. What begins as an act of compassion risks ending up as a quiet form of controlling the cost of health care. 14:43 A system that tells the most vulnerable among us, we can't fix your life, but we can help you end it. And when society reaches the point where death becomes a public policy decision, you've crossed the Rubicon. 14:56 It tells you far more about the culture of living than the fate of the dying. Wit and Wisdom is a free weekly podcast for people who are curious about the world. 15:07 If you learned something today, or if this podcast challenged you, or it made you think differently about the world, how about sharing it with a few people you care about? 15:16 Maybe you too can have your own honest conversation about the things that really matter. So thanks again for tuning in. I hope you'll come back next week for another episode of Wit and Wisdom. 15:28 And in the meantime, always remember, nothing beats nice.