Transcript 0:01 Thanks for tuning in to Wit and Wisdom with Tom Green, where we start conversations on the things that really matter. So let's see, this is episode number 149 of the Wit and Wisdom podcast. 0:14 And after you listen, I'd love to hear your feedback. You can always email me, that's t at tomgreen with an e on the end dot com. Or you're welcome to leave a comment. You can do that on all the major podcast platforms. 0:27 That includes Spotify, iTunes, Google, and even iHeartRadio. 0:34 And if you enjoyed this episode, I hope you'll subscribe and share it with a couple of friends who might be looking for a new podcast, because we're always looking for new friends. So let's jump in. 0:44 Welcome to episode number 149. There was a time not so long ago when shame was a guardrail. It didn't just keep us in line, it actually showed us where the line was. 0:58 You didn't air your dirty laundry in public, and you certainly didn't flaunt your sexual escapades if you even had any. Back then, shame wasn't seen as oppression. 1:11 It was a social safety net to keep you from, well, yourself. You might think of it as the conscience of the community. In many cultures, bringing shame to oneself or to one's family was the ultimate sin. 1:26 You didn't need laws to stop people from doing things that were unthinkable. Just the thought of being found out was enough. Neighbors knew each other, and you cared what each other thought. 1:38 Church pews were full, not just for worship, but for the community that was found there. I'll be the first to admit that at times that shame thing got a little carried away. 1:49 But there were checks and balances, and it all kind of worked out. There was an understanding that certain things were private, and privacy itself was sacred. 2:00 Growing up in the 1980s, the most scandalous thing you might see on TV was an unmarried couple kissing with the lights on. Just imagine what the hit show Friends might look like today on Netflix. 2:13 In hindsight, that show was squeaky clean. But since that time, our moral compass has lost its ability to find true north. And as we say in the South, shame just up and died. Television used to blush. 2:31 Think about it. A show like Three's Company was considered risque because it hinted, it just hinted, at sexual innuendo. Today, the main character, Jack, would be in bed with both of the girls. 2:44 The cultural guardrails that once contained our impulses have been replaced by the algorithms that amplify them. How sad. Today, there's a reality television show called Love Island. I doubt you've ever heard of it. 2:58 It runs on Hulu, Peacock, and Amazon Prime. And the premise is that it quarantines 10 beautiful singles in a luxurious villa, most recently in Mallorca. 3:10 Every inch of the villa is filmed 24 by 7 by a production crew who's always watching. To stay in the game, you must couple up with each other and share a bed with a different person each week. 3:24 The contestants, known as Islanders, all sleep in one big room with a bunch of beds. You can't make this up. The producers use night vision cameras to film anyone making the two-headed sheet monster after dark. 3:38 There's lots of whispering and giggling under the sheets after dark. Not a lot is left to the imagination. There's not a lot of humility, and there's definitely no shame. 3:50 If shame had a grave, you could visit it on this show. What used to be hidden behind closed doors is now out in the open. Beautiful men and women bouncing around in bathing suits with spray tans. 4:03 The sexual tension on the show is palpable. Instead of Three's Company, it's actually more like Ten's Company. See, reality television has blurred the line between intimacy and entertainment. 4:17 What once required privacy now demands an audience. Pew Research found that 58% of young adults say sharing your life publicly is now a form of authenticity, not attention-seeking. 4:31 In other words, the modern moral code rewards exposure, not restraint. Great. Every few days on the show, new contestants are added just to spice things up. You can imagine what happens next. 4:46 It's like The Bachelor meets The Dating Game. Just add in spray tans, body art, abs, and sex. Lots of sex. Which raises the question, how badly must you want to be famous to participate in this garbage? 5:03 And how damaged is your moral compass to think this is the launch pad of your big acting career? Have you no shame? 5:10 Surely your mom and dad, your grandparents, and your little sisters back in Poughkeepsie are watching your big break on television. How sad. But it's not just Love Island. 5:24 This cultural exhibitionism has infected nearly every corner of entertainment. Shows like Too Hot to Handle, The Circle, and Naked Attraction. Can you imagine what that one's about? 5:37 Each new series pushes the boundary a little further, betting that shock equals engagement. And it often does. 5:45 According to Gallup, the share of Americans who believe television and movies have a negative influence on moral values has jumped to 73%. Yet, we keep watching. 5:58 It sounds like trash nobody would watch, right?Well, shockingly, Season seven, which was this season, had eighteen point four billion minutes streamed over its six-week run. Now, I had to put that in context. 6:14 First, it was Peacock's most-watched original series ever. But in comparison, the hit show The Bear Season three and Bridgerton Season two only racked up one point two billion minutes each. 6:30 Yes, things that once provoked shame now provoked likes and billions of minutes of screen time. How on earth did we get here? I think we got here because we mistook visibility for virtue. 6:45 We started to believe that as long as something is filmed, posted, or authentic, it must also be acceptable. That we shouldn't have any judgment. That's the slippery slope of moral relativism. 7:00 When you remove shame, you remove the friction that once forced reflection. Everything becomes performance, even morality itself. And this is the age of moral relativism, 7:14 the belief that morality has no single objective standard of right and wrong. Morality today is shaped by culture, by context, or simply by personal preference, meaning that the definition of right and wrong is fluid. 7:29 It's subject to whatever each person thinks. In theory, that sounds tolerant. Who am I to tell you what's best for you, right? 7:39 But in practice, moral relativism is what allows young people to justify having sex with multiple strangers each week while millions of viewers watch, including their own families. 7:52 A twenty twenty-four Pew study found that sixty-five percent of Americans now say there's no clear right or wrong in most situations. Think about that. 8:01 Nearly two-thirds of the country believe that morality is context-dependent, that your truth might not be my truth. That belief makes shame impossible because shame depends on shared standards. 8:15 If everyone defines their own right and wrong, then where are the boundaries? What a horrible idea. This isn't just about nostalgia for the good old days of Little House on the Prairie. 8:29 It's about desensitization, because the more we see something, the less it shocks us. And over time, what was once shameful becomes trendy, and eventually, nothing shocks us anymore. 8:44 And the next television show, like Love Island, will have to raise the bar. Perhaps they'll all just run around naked and frolic in the sand for all to see. It's not beyond the realm of possibility. That's where we are. 8:59 Psychologists call it moral habituation. The first time you see something offensive, you recoil. The second time, you shrug. By the tenth time you see it, you barely even notice. Our brains normalize the abnormal. 9:14 It's not new. The Romans did it with gladiators. We just do it today with content, and the difference is scale. Today, you can stream moral erosion to millions in 4K on demand and make a lot of money doing it. 9:31 See, shame used to be a guardrail of sorts. If you cheated, you lied, or you acted selfishly, others judged you, and social consequences followed. But shame today is dead. 9:44 Apparently, nobody wants to be the morality police in the age of tolerance. The irony is that our hyper-tolerant culture has become intolerant of moral conviction. 9:57 To express disgust, to say, "That's wrong," is now seen as judgmental or maybe even out of date. It's a bigger sin than the act itself. 10:09 A Gallup poll found that only twenty-four percent of Americans say they feel comfortable expressing their moral beliefs in public. We've replaced moral courage with moral silence. 10:22 The death of shame leaves guilt as the primary moral compass. Guilt is the little voice of conscience in your head, but guilt is easily overridden by attention-seeking incentives. 10:34 Social media likes and views now carry more weight than any universal principles of right and wrong. 10:41 With garbage like Love Island on TV, it's not surprising that eighty-three percent of Americans think US moral values are getting worse. No surprise. 10:51 Once we get on the moral slip and slide, there's simply no turning back. Take pornography and polygamy, for example. 10:59 According to a twenty twenty-three Gallup survey, a record high number of Americans now view pornography and even polygamy as morally acceptable. 11:09 To put it in context, forty-one percent think pornography is morally acceptable, and twenty-three percent believe even polygamy is morally acceptable. 11:19 And these are the highest numbers ever recorded, at least since Gallup started the survey. And it's not just these two. The same poll shows rising acceptance of casual sex, marijuana use, and assisted suicide. 11:34 Even adultery, long considered an ethical red line, has doubled in moral acceptability since two thousand and one. 11:42 Meanwhile, fewer than twenty percent of Americans now describe themselves as very satisfied with the moral climate of the country. In other words, everyone sees the erosion, but no one wants to say anything. 11:56 The problem with moral relativism is that there's no foundation, no code. 12:02 What's right or wrong today is full of algorithmic reinforcement.See, platforms reward content that shocks or entertains rather than educates or upholds any traditional moral standard. 12:13 Incentive distort what behaviors are normalized. Likes replace the quiet voice of conscience. Yes, shame is dead today, replaced by the temporal applause of strangers. 12:28 It seems we've outsourced moral authority to the mob. Social media now sets more behavioral norms than parents, pastors, or teachers. 12:37 And according to Pew Research, nearly forty percent of adults under thirty say social media is their main source of moral and social guidance. Our collective conscience has been replaced by an infinite scroll. 12:50 See, morality was never intended to be crowdsourced and validated by views and likes, but that's where we are. 12:59 See, when everything today can be filmed, can be shared and monetized, the only true sin left is being boring. But the absence of shame doesn't make us free. It makes us hollow. Maybe it's time we brought shame back, 13:15 not to humiliate people, but to humble. Because shame at its best wasn't about punishment. It was about conscience. It reminded us that there was a line, and crossing that line meant something. 13:31 Shame once kept us tethered to each other. It said, "Your behavior impacts me." Its absence has made us lonely, narcissistic, and numb. A society without shame doesn't evolve, it decays. 13:47 Gallup reports that the rates of loneliness, depression, and moral exhaustion are at record highs. Coincidence? Probably not. The moral void leaves a spiritual void as well. 14:02 Reintroducing shame doesn't mean we return to public stonings or scarlet letters. Far from it. It means we just rediscover humility, the kind that whispers. 14:13 It means teaching our kids that dignity is more valuable than fame. It means understanding that there's a difference between being seen and being known. Because shame, when healthy, wasn't designed to destroy you. 14:29 It was actually meant to save you from everyone, but mostly from yourself. Wit and Wisdom is a free community of people who are curious about the world. Our newsletter comes out every Monday via email. 14:47 It's always free, and we're always looking for new friends. And of course, you can always subscribe on this or any other major podcast platform. We'd love to have you join us at Wit and Wisdom. 15:01 We're always having conversations on the things that really matter. So if you've learned something today, or if this podcast challenged you, or just made you think differently about the world, 15:15 would you mind taking a minute and sharing it with some people you care about? Maybe you, too, can have your own honest conversation about the things that really matter. So thanks again for tuning in. 15:30 I hope you'll come back next week for another episode of Wit and Wisdom. And in the meantime, as always, remember, nothing beats nice.