You’ve heard it before: most of the things we worry about never actually happen. It’s not a new thought. The world’s greatest Philosophers and thinkers have repeated this since Socrates was a boy.
Nearly two thousand years ago, Marcus Aurelius observed that when we are distressed, it is rarely the event itself that troubles us, but our judgment about it. The blow will only land once. But we practice for it 1,000 times. Envisioning all the worst case scenarios—the parade of horribles—in our head.
See, we are not genetically wired to see things as they are. We are wired to scan for danger. The brain always defaults to threat detection before the rational mind has time to object. Mouth gets dry. Heart rate ticks up. Muscles tighten. The body prepares for a predator that may exist only in our mind.
Worry often gives a small thing a big shadow
We borrow trouble from the future. We replay trouble from the past. Then we wonder why the present feels impossible to inhabit.
The Tyranny of Anticipation
Most anticipation has very little to do with the present. It lives in the future. As Brene Brown once said, “we dress rehearse for tragedy”.
The phone call that hasn’t come.
The diagnosis that hasn’t been delivered.
The conversation you keep rehearsing in the shower.
The failure that has not occurred — and statistically, probably never will.
Some of you will get this analogy, some of you won’t.
Michel de Montaigne understood this intuitively. Fear, he suggested, does not politely wait for evidence. It arrives early. It sets up camp. It begins charging rent. The remarkable part is not that thinkers like Montaigne noticed this tendency. It’s that centuries later, we still refuse to believe them.
Marcus Aurelius pushed the idea further. The event itself, he argued, is neutral. It is our interpretation that generates suffering. Trouble is inevitable. Suffering, to a large extent, is imaginary.
We borrow trouble from the future, replay trouble from the past, and then wonder why the present feels unlivable.
When something difficult actually happens, it hurts once. But when we anticipate it obsessively, we endure it dozens — sometimes hundreds — of times before reality ever has a chance to speak for itself.
Wit & Wisdom can now be found in 27 newspapers. Know anybody in the newspaper or digital media biz? I would love an introduction. Many thanks.
Seneca’s Warning
Seneca the Younger warned that this habit weakens us. A person who is constantly bracing for catastrophe is already exhausted before the trial arrives. Fear, he argued, makes us less capable—not more prepared. Worrying in advance feels like vigilance.
If this guy was “Seneca the Younger”, what did “Seneca the Older” look like?
No matter the outcome, we just don’t want to be surprised. And we often convince ourselves that if we can predict it we can preempt it. That if we think hard enough about worst-case scenarios, we can somehow outmaneuver fate. But the ancients knew better. You cannot outthink the future. You can only destroy the present.
Do you know someone who is going through a rough season of life? Why not forward this column to them?
Pascal’s Dark Turn
Blaise Pascal took a darker view. He believed we instinctively understand how unsettling our own thoughts can be. That is why we fill silence so aggressively. Doomscrolling. Podcasts. Social media. Background noise in every quiet moment.
The result is a culture constantly on edge, constantly waiting for the other shoe to drop. Not a crisis — just constant vigilance. A permanent readiness for something that may never arrive.
Modern systems amplify this tendency. News cycles trade in hypothetical catastrophes. Social platforms reward outrage about events that will never directly touch our lives. Algorithms drip-feed just enough alarm to keep us engaged, rarely enough resolution to let us exhale.
You cannot outthink the future. You can only destroy the present.
To say that much of our suffering is imagined does not mean bad things don’t happen. They do. Preparation is not foolish. Grief is not fictional. But imagined suffering deserves examination. Not every thought deserves belief. Not every scenario deserves rehearsal.
A More Humane Way to Live
The shared insight of Montaigne, Marcus Aurelius, Seneca, and Pascal is that we make life harder than it needs to be. We bleed internally over futures that never arrive. We rehearse grief prematurely. We exhaust ourselves carrying burdens that have no weight outside the mind.
A more humane way to live does not require eliminating fear. It requires interrogating it. Asking, calmly: Is this happening now? Is this certain? Or is this my mind running simulations again?
The phone may never ring.
The diagnosis may be benign.
The conversation you worried about for months is resolved in a ten minute conversation.
The failure never happens.
The mind will always generate monsters. That is its nature. Wisdom is learning which monsters deserve your attention — and which ones are only shadows cast by imagination across a perfectly ordinary day.
The irony is painful: in trying to protect ourselves from suffering, we create it. A better life doesn’t require eliminating fear. It requires learning when fear is lying. And that, perhaps, is the quiet freedom these thinkers were pointing toward all along—not control over events, but restraint over imagination.
Because the mind will always generate monsters. Wisdom is knowing which ones are real.
I’d love to hear what you think of this article. Leave me a message by clicking the link below. I promise that you’ll hear back from me cause, you know, I’m a real person and all.
If you’re new to Wit & Wisdom, we’d love for you to join our community of 25K readers. The newsletter comes out every Monday via email. It’s always free, and we are always looking for new friends. Please join us.
